DAVIDYEK
  • Home
  • About
    • Professional Registration
    • Qualifications
    • Engagements
    • Private Practice
    • SIF Fellows
  • Practice
    • Our Approach >
      • S:Scale [Artefacts]
      • M:Scale [Building]
      • L:Scale [Urban]
    • Large Projects >
      • Highrises >
        • SSM International School
        • JBio
        • UKIH
        • Vertigo Residency
        • Diorama
        • Resi-Hub
        • SunMed
        • Medini
        • Palmspring Damansara
        • Blink
      • Lowrises >
        • Data Center
        • Garden Homes
        • XIN
        • Albient
        • Hillcourt
    • Small Projects >
      • Rustic Raphsody
      • MCM >
        • Estate House
        • Uniform Annex
        • Kitchen Extension
        • Sixth Form Center
      • Putrajaya Boulevard >
        • LOO
        • BOO
        • DOO
        • 5 Elements Tower
      • Detached Houses >
        • Batu Residence
        • Malaqa Residence
        • ParkCity Residence
        • Sierramas Residence
      • Commercial >
        • Albion Club
        • QuanYuan
        • Nippon Go
    • Interior Designs >
      • Spartan Minimalism
      • Neo Retro
      • Reflective Modern
    • UBBL 1984
    • Newsletter
  • DYA + C
    • Our CV
    • Adjudication >
      • CIPAA Procedure >
        • Scope of CIPAA
    • Arbitration >
      • Appointment of Arbitrator >
        • Terms of Appointment >
          • Preliminary Meeting Agenda
      • PAM Arbitration Procedure
      • Arbitration Costs Breakdowns >
        • Drawdown
      • Award Writing Blog >
        • Expert Evidence in Arbitration
    • Mediation >
      • Appointment of Mediator
      • Mediation Process
      • Skill Set Lev 01 & 02
    • Expert Determination >
      • Expert Rules - PAM
      • Expert Determination Processes
    • Building Inspection Services
    • Courses & Training >
      • Contract Administration
    • ADR & Construction Law
  • Consultant
    • QuanYuan 泉緣 Story
    • Review
    • QuanYuan >
      • Why QuanYuan?
      • Modus Operandi
      • Consultancy Services
    • Our Lineage
    • Workshop >
      • Teacher's Profiles
      • Message
      • SanYuan 01 - Introduction
      • Community
      • Registration of Interest
    • QiMen DunJia 奇門遁甲 >
      • QMDJ - Shifting Palace
    • Audit & Cases >
      • Cases - REA Hotel
      • Cases - Childless Couple
      • Cases - Childless Couple 02
    • Yifengshui
    • Newsletter >
      • MBS FengShui Reinvestigated
    • FAQ
    • E-Store
  • Educator
    • Author I am...
    • Speaking Engagement >
      • International Contract
      • PAM cpd UNLIMITED 2.0
      • Arch Edu Practice Paper - 3Ds Pedagogy
    • Attempting Law School
    • Journey in USM(Arch) >
      • Thesis >
        • Site Analysis
        • Urban Design Approach
        • Sketch Design
        • Model Based Paradigm
        • Technical Studies
      • Studio 01
      • Studio 02
    • Discourse in Studio 6 >
      • Ideation
      • The Production Model >
        • The Actors
        • The Stage
        • Urban Mass
        • The Box
        • The Play
        • The Break
        • The Newsletter
        • The Document
        • The Presentation
    • d:KON 4 >
      • Actors >
        • Chua LiCheng
        • Ng KenHong
        • Sean Tan
        • Peggy Chai
        • Elliotte Teoh
        • Vincent Tow
        • TzeLer
        • Elaine
        • Ng SongChun
        • Carissa Foong
        • Ng WeiMun
        • Ng ChenYin
        • Nicol Ong
        • Adron Liang
        • Ivan Sung
        • Lau HuiJew
      • Acts >
        • Portraiture
        • A Slice of Space Time
        • Box of Installation of Lights
        • Radio Misreading
        • Grid of Destinies
        • Shelter
        • Anatomy of Pain
        • Tensigrity of Ego
        • Of Prisons and Walls
        • Forest of Nails
        • Curtain of Fears
        • Dissolution of the Ego
        • If it's Ain't Broken it's Ain't Worth Mending
        • Flight of Freedom
        • Cross of Complexity and Contradiction
        • interrogation
      • Stage >
        • Soap Box
      • Play
      • Approach
      • Galleria >
        • Martial Gallery
        • Drive Through Gallery
        • Clinique Gallery
        • Cafe Gallery
        • MACC Gallery
        • Haunted Gallery
        • Backpacker Hotel
        • Audio Bookshop Gallery
        • Funeral Parlour
        • Extreme Game Gallery
        • Play Ground
        • Wedding Gallery
        • Meditation Gallery
        • Water Tower
        • Photography Studio
        • Chapel Gallery
    • External Critique >
      • Discourse in Sem 06
      • Discourse in Sem 05 >
        • The Site - KB
        • The Rectilinear
        • The Paired Kidneys
        • The Boat
        • The Decepticon
        • The Curvature
      • EnviroDesign MasterClass 2015
    • Philosophy
    • Codes Regulations & Standards >
      • Building Codes
      • Fire Codes
      • QAQC & Building Inspection
      • Critics
  • Photo Essays
    • Shanghai
    • Siemreap
  • Contact

WARRANTY, DEFECT LIABILITY, LONGSTOP … WHERE IS THE LIMIT?

11/12/2020

2 Comments

 
Picture

​WARRANTY, DEFECT LIABILITY, LONGSTOP … WHERE IS THE LIMIT?

The 2 years’ Defect Liability Period (DLP), commencing from Vacant Possession (VP), is not a warranty? If so, what is a warranty?
 
Law of obligation suggests that whether a contract is held to be a condition, warranty or an innominate term is a fundamentally important distinctions. A breach in warranties, does not warrant the end of the contract, may give rise to right to sue for damages, i.e. loss due to defective work.[1]  Only court could determine the kind of remedy either right to terminate or damages only. [2]  In so doing, the court rely on, any detrimental cause foreseeable? Any delay caused? Value of performance not breach? Cost involved in conforming to the contract? Opportunity enjoyed by the defaulting party? Any consequences of prior-breach? Whether victim has been adequately compensated?

In essence, Malaysian court held that the law do not deprive the right of the owner to claim the developers for their right for having premises in the good and workmanlike manner.[3] It implies that the warranty does not stop at DLP. It is relatively easier to claim for damages under DLP, i.e. a defect form is filled up and the contractor shall rectify the defect in the time stipulated in the Sale and Purchase Agreement (SPA), as it is contractual. Above that, it has to proof negligence under Tort.[4]

Such proof of negligence is under the purview of the Limitation (Amendment) Act 2018 (Act) from its predecessor[5], actions in contract and tort shall be time-barred after the expiration of six years from the date on which the cause of action accrued; 6-year limitation period applies notwithstanding when the plaintiff discovers the damages.[6] This approach were heavily criticised being unjust where latent defects (non-visible), not immediately detectable upon inspection are discovered after the six-year limitation period.[7]

The amendment of the Act, introduces s.6A, with the 6-year time-barred remains when criteria are, action brought after the expiration period; due to negligence not involving personal injury; and action be brought within three years from the "starting date" and subject to a longstop of 15 years. The amended Act provided a ‘long-stop’ to any act of negligence not amounting to personal injury for the Developer and Contractor but not the Architect.
 
There is a catch. The amended Act defines "starting date" as “the earliest date on which the plaintiff or any person in whom the cause of action was vested before him first had both the knowledge required … and a right to bring such action.”[8] ; Commencement depends on the person’s first knowledge; deemed to have the requisite knowledge when he knows of the damage for which it is claimed; and other facts relevant to the action, […][9]; implied with external expert’s advice; i.e. the "discoverability rule". So, there is in-reality, no end to be found.
 
DLP remains a warranty period under the contract provision but not tort liability, of just, fair and reasonable.[10] There is yet to be a finality to the issue of ‘long-stop’. Mirrored the English courts, there have not restricted application in UK's Limitation Act.[11] That is to say, for the Architects, Engineers and the allied professionals, alike, the liability under Street, Drainage and Building Act 1974 is for perpetuity and the ‘long-stop’ does not apply.[12]

------------------------------------------------------

[1] Bettini v Gye(1876)1QBD183
[2] Hong Kong Fir Shipping v Kawasaki Kisen[1962]2QB26
[3] The Ara Joint Management Body v Mammoth Land & Development Sdn Bhd [2017] MLJU 631; Fong Wan Reality v PJ Condominium S/B [2010]10 CLJ 112
[4] Donoghue v Stevenson[1932]AC562; Hedley Byrne v Heller[1964]AC465; and Junior Books v Veitchi[1983]1AC520
[5] Limitation Act 1953 (Limitation Act)
[6] AmBank (M) Bhd v Abdul Aziz Hassan & Ors [2010] 3 MLJ 784
[7] Sharikat Ying Mui Sdn Bhd v Hoh Kiang Po [2015] MLJU 621
[8] S.6A(4)(a)
[9] S.6A(4)(b)
[10] Caparo Industries v Dickman[1990] 1AC.605
[11] s.14A, UK's Limitation Act 1980: Haward and others v Fawcetts (a firm) [2006] 3 All ER 497; and Blakemores LDP (in administration) v Scott and others [2015] EWCA Civ 999
[12] Bellefield Computer Services v E. Turner & Sons Ltd (No. 2) [2002] EWCA Civ 1823
2 Comments

    DYA+C

    Author

    DYA+C is set up by Ar. DAVID YEK TAK WAI to undertake resolution of commercial disputes through ARBITRATION and ADJUDICATION, specializing in CONSTRUCTION PAYMENT DISPUTES.

    This is an educational blog. We do not guarantee, confirm nor warrant the accuracy of the information and facts stated therein. Read at your own 'risk'.

    Archives

    December 2022
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    April 2019
    December 2018

    Categories

    All
    AALCO
    Acific Associates V Baxter [1989]2AllER159
    ACP
    Act Of Criminal
    Ad Hoc Mediation
    Adjudication
    AIAC
    AIAC Form
    Arbitration
    Arbitration Conference 2018
    Arenson V Casson Beckman Rutley [1977]AC405
    Art 121 Federal Constitution
    Art7(ad)PAM2006
    Art.7 PAM 2006
    Bellefield Computer Services V E. Turner & Sons Ltd (No. 2) [2002]
    Bettini V Gye (1876)
    Bias
    Bills Of Quantities BQ
    Blakemores LDP (in Administration) V Scott And Others [2015]
    Board Of Architect Malaysia LAM
    Cadenvish Case UK
    Canary Wharf V. EMA [2019]
    Caparo Industries V Dickman [1990]
    Carillion Collapsed
    CCC
    Certifier
    CFO
    Chambers V Goldthorpe [1901]
    Chitty On Contracts
    CIArb
    CIDB
    CIDB Form
    CIMB Bank Bhd V Anthony Lawrence Bourke & Anor [2019]
    CIPAA
    Clause 1.4
    Clause 18
    Clause 2.0
    Clause 21.4
    Clause 23.10
    Clause 23.1(a)
    Clause 23.5(b)
    Clause 23.8(a)
    Clause 23.8(w)
    Clause 24.1(b)
    Clause 24.3(c)
    Clause 24.3(n)
    Clause 2.(a)
    Clause 3.1
    Clause 4.1
    Clause 4.3
    Clause 7.1
    Confidentiality
    Construction Law
    Contract Administration
    CPC
    Cubic Electronic Vs Mars Telecommunications
    Defect Liability
    Delay
    Disclosure
    Discrepancy Dwgs-Bills
    Dispute Clause
    Drawings
    Dysfunctional Arbitration Agreement
    EOT
    Evaluative Mediation
    Ezumi
    FIDIC Form
    Final Costs
    Fong Wan Reality V PJ Condominium S/B [2010]
    Force Majeure
    Fraudulent Misrepresentation
    Frustration
    Goh Teng Whoo & Anor V Ample Objectives
    Good-Faith
    Guan Aik Moh (KL) Sdn Bhd & Anor V Selangor Properties Bhd [2007]
    Hadley V Baxendale [1854]
    Halliburton V Chubb [2020]
    Haward And Others V Fawcetts (a Firm) [2006]
    HDA
    HGCRA
    Hong Kong Fir Shipping V Kawasaki Kisen [1962]
    IEM Form
    Immunity
    Impartiality
    Incorporation Of Societies
    Independence And Impartiality
    Infectious Diseases Act 1988
    Initial Costs
    Intan Payong Sdn Bhd V. Goh Saw Chan Sdn Bhd [2004]
    JKR Form
    KKM
    KLRCA
    Krell V Henry [1903]
    Li Ching Wing V Xuan Yi Xiong [2004]
    Limitation Act 1953
    Limitation (Amendment) Act 2018
    Liquidated Damages
    Lok Kok Beng V Loh Chiak Eong [2015] 7 CLJ 1008
    Long-Stop
    Loss & Expense
    Low & Associates) V Persatuan Kanak Kanak Spastik Selangor & Wilayah Persekutuan And Another Case [2021] MLJU 430
    Low & Associates) V Persatuan Kanak-Kanak Spastik Selangor & Wilayah Persekutuan And Another Case [2021] MLJU 430
    Masenang Sdn Bhd V Sabanilam Enterprise Sdn Bhd
    MBank (M) Bhd V Abdul Aziz Hassan & Ors [2010]
    MCO
    Mears V Costplan [2019] EWCA Civ 502
    MITI
    Mitigation
    MKN
    NEC Form
    Pacific Forest Industries Sdn Bhd V Lin Wen-Chih [2009]
    PAM
    PAM Advisory
    PAM Form
    PAM Mediation
    PAM-Mediation
    Party Autonomy
    Pathological Defects
    PCP V L3 [2019]1LNS1321
    Police Act 1967
    Postal Rule
    PPE
    Preliminaries
    Prolongation Costs
    Public Policy
    PWD Form
    Qimonda V Sediabena (2012)
    Recurrent Costs
    Renegotiation
    Retention-Money
    RIBA Form
    S.14 Malaysian Arbitration Act 2005
    S.15 – 16 Civil Law Act 1956 CLA
    S.22 Arbitration Act 2005
    S.57(2) CA 1950
    S.70(21)SBDA1974
    Saga Fire Engineering V Lee Yee Seng [2017]
    SBDA 1974
    Schedule Of Rates
    Seat
    Selvakumar Vs Thiagarajah
    Serving Of Notice
    Sharikat Ying Mui Sdn Bhd V Hoh Kiang Po [2015]
    SK M&E Bersekutu V Pembinaan Legenda Unggul (2019)
    Skyworld Development Sdn Bhd V. Zalam Corporation Sdn Bhd & Other Cases. [2019]
    Societies Act 1966
    SOPL
    Standard Form Of Building Contract
    Statute Of Limitation
    Sutcliffe V Thackrah [1974]
    Temporary Measures For Reducing The Impact Of Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID 19)
    Temporary Measures For Reducing The Impact Of Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
    The Ara Joint Management Body V Mammoth Land & Development Sdn Bhd [2017]
    Trust Law
    UBBL 1984
    UK's Limitation Act 1980
    Ultra Vires
    VP
    Warranty
    Working Days

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
  • About
    • Professional Registration
    • Qualifications
    • Engagements
    • Private Practice
    • SIF Fellows
  • Practice
    • Our Approach >
      • S:Scale [Artefacts]
      • M:Scale [Building]
      • L:Scale [Urban]
    • Large Projects >
      • Highrises >
        • SSM International School
        • JBio
        • UKIH
        • Vertigo Residency
        • Diorama
        • Resi-Hub
        • SunMed
        • Medini
        • Palmspring Damansara
        • Blink
      • Lowrises >
        • Data Center
        • Garden Homes
        • XIN
        • Albient
        • Hillcourt
    • Small Projects >
      • Rustic Raphsody
      • MCM >
        • Estate House
        • Uniform Annex
        • Kitchen Extension
        • Sixth Form Center
      • Putrajaya Boulevard >
        • LOO
        • BOO
        • DOO
        • 5 Elements Tower
      • Detached Houses >
        • Batu Residence
        • Malaqa Residence
        • ParkCity Residence
        • Sierramas Residence
      • Commercial >
        • Albion Club
        • QuanYuan
        • Nippon Go
    • Interior Designs >
      • Spartan Minimalism
      • Neo Retro
      • Reflective Modern
    • UBBL 1984
    • Newsletter
  • DYA + C
    • Our CV
    • Adjudication >
      • CIPAA Procedure >
        • Scope of CIPAA
    • Arbitration >
      • Appointment of Arbitrator >
        • Terms of Appointment >
          • Preliminary Meeting Agenda
      • PAM Arbitration Procedure
      • Arbitration Costs Breakdowns >
        • Drawdown
      • Award Writing Blog >
        • Expert Evidence in Arbitration
    • Mediation >
      • Appointment of Mediator
      • Mediation Process
      • Skill Set Lev 01 & 02
    • Expert Determination >
      • Expert Rules - PAM
      • Expert Determination Processes
    • Building Inspection Services
    • Courses & Training >
      • Contract Administration
    • ADR & Construction Law
  • Consultant
    • QuanYuan 泉緣 Story
    • Review
    • QuanYuan >
      • Why QuanYuan?
      • Modus Operandi
      • Consultancy Services
    • Our Lineage
    • Workshop >
      • Teacher's Profiles
      • Message
      • SanYuan 01 - Introduction
      • Community
      • Registration of Interest
    • QiMen DunJia 奇門遁甲 >
      • QMDJ - Shifting Palace
    • Audit & Cases >
      • Cases - REA Hotel
      • Cases - Childless Couple
      • Cases - Childless Couple 02
    • Yifengshui
    • Newsletter >
      • MBS FengShui Reinvestigated
    • FAQ
    • E-Store
  • Educator
    • Author I am...
    • Speaking Engagement >
      • International Contract
      • PAM cpd UNLIMITED 2.0
      • Arch Edu Practice Paper - 3Ds Pedagogy
    • Attempting Law School
    • Journey in USM(Arch) >
      • Thesis >
        • Site Analysis
        • Urban Design Approach
        • Sketch Design
        • Model Based Paradigm
        • Technical Studies
      • Studio 01
      • Studio 02
    • Discourse in Studio 6 >
      • Ideation
      • The Production Model >
        • The Actors
        • The Stage
        • Urban Mass
        • The Box
        • The Play
        • The Break
        • The Newsletter
        • The Document
        • The Presentation
    • d:KON 4 >
      • Actors >
        • Chua LiCheng
        • Ng KenHong
        • Sean Tan
        • Peggy Chai
        • Elliotte Teoh
        • Vincent Tow
        • TzeLer
        • Elaine
        • Ng SongChun
        • Carissa Foong
        • Ng WeiMun
        • Ng ChenYin
        • Nicol Ong
        • Adron Liang
        • Ivan Sung
        • Lau HuiJew
      • Acts >
        • Portraiture
        • A Slice of Space Time
        • Box of Installation of Lights
        • Radio Misreading
        • Grid of Destinies
        • Shelter
        • Anatomy of Pain
        • Tensigrity of Ego
        • Of Prisons and Walls
        • Forest of Nails
        • Curtain of Fears
        • Dissolution of the Ego
        • If it's Ain't Broken it's Ain't Worth Mending
        • Flight of Freedom
        • Cross of Complexity and Contradiction
        • interrogation
      • Stage >
        • Soap Box
      • Play
      • Approach
      • Galleria >
        • Martial Gallery
        • Drive Through Gallery
        • Clinique Gallery
        • Cafe Gallery
        • MACC Gallery
        • Haunted Gallery
        • Backpacker Hotel
        • Audio Bookshop Gallery
        • Funeral Parlour
        • Extreme Game Gallery
        • Play Ground
        • Wedding Gallery
        • Meditation Gallery
        • Water Tower
        • Photography Studio
        • Chapel Gallery
    • External Critique >
      • Discourse in Sem 06
      • Discourse in Sem 05 >
        • The Site - KB
        • The Rectilinear
        • The Paired Kidneys
        • The Boat
        • The Decepticon
        • The Curvature
      • EnviroDesign MasterClass 2015
    • Philosophy
    • Codes Regulations & Standards >
      • Building Codes
      • Fire Codes
      • QAQC & Building Inspection
      • Critics
  • Photo Essays
    • Shanghai
    • Siemreap
  • Contact